Their testing includes you!


The age of two can be a very difficult time for parents and caregivers. Children at this age are growing more independent and sometimes they do things adults don’t want them to do. If it seems like children are intentionally disobeying or disregarding their caregivers’ wishes—it’s because they are! But they are not trying to drive you crazy on purpose.

While two-year-olds’ behavior is difficult to deal with at times, it is only part of the story. It may seem hard to believe, but these children actually have good reasons for their actions. They are learning what happens when people want different things and they are fascinated by these differences. In other words, they are learning about conflict and are using a powerful learning mechanism —hypothesis testing. The age of two is

really just a part of children’s experimental program to figure out the world and their need to understand other people. Primary caregivers are the main test subjects! (Gopnik, Meltzoff & Kuhl, 1999)

They want to learn how conflict works.

By the age of two, children are trying to understand conflict. At younger ages, children believe that their desires (what they want, what they like) are the same as everyone else’s desires. When everyone wants and likes the same things, there’s no real conflict. But at around 18 months, children begin to understand an important new concept: people have different desires. (Gopnik et al.,1999)

How do we know this? One creative experiment, using crackers and broccoli, gives us solid evidence (Repacholi & Gopnik, 1997). Researchers showed 14-month-old and 18-month-old children two different bowls of food—one filled with Goldfish crackers and one filled with raw broccoli. When given the choice between the two foods, both the 14-month-old and 18-month-old children chose the crackers.

Next, a researcher tasted the foods in front of the babies. When she ate the crackers, she made a disgusted face and said, “Yuck.” With the broccoli, she smiled and said, “Yum.” Then, with both bowls of food in front of her, she put out her hands and asked the babies to give her some food. This was the experimental question: Would the babies give her some crackers or some broccoli?

The 14-month-old babies gave the researcher crackers, even though she said “yuck” when she ate them before. They didn’t yet understand how another person could want or prefer something different from their own tastes and desires.

The 18-month-old babies gave the researcher broccoli, showing that despite their own preference for crackers, they understood that the adult preferred the vegetable. They understood that the adult had different desires for food.

In other words, 18-month-old children are beginning to understand that people are different, and that what they want is not necessarily what adults want. (Repacholi & Gopnik, 1997) And this is a recipe for conflict. Children need to learn how conflict works—and how to resolve it.

How children learn—hypothesis testing and conflict.

To learn about conflict, two year-old toddlers launch a series of experiments. This process is called hypothesis testing, and it is a powerful way that children (and scientists) learn about the world. It starts with what children already know about people and their desires. With this knowledge, children make predictions (hypotheses) and test them to see if their ideas are correct.

Hypothesis testing involves five steps:

  1. Making observations
  2. Asking questions
  3. Creating hypotheses (what they think will happen based on what they know)
  4. Testing hypotheses
  5. Evaluating the evidence

For example, let’s take a two-year-old who has just grabbed his mom’s lipstick. He really wants to make a big red streak on the wall, but he thinks his mother might not like it if he does. He’s trying to learn how his mother will react.

Here’s what hypothesis testing might look like:

  1. “I have mom’s lipstick and I want to make a big red mark on the wall. I know that my mom doesn’t want me to mark on the wall.” (Observation)
  2. “What will happen if I do what I want and make a big red mark with the lipstick?” (Question)
  3. “When I used a crayon to mark on the wall, mom got angry. I think she might get angry again.” (Hypothesis)
  4. “Here I go, even though mom has a bad look on her face!” (Testing)
  5. “Mom got really angry — and this is what it’s like when she’s angry." (Evaluating the evidence)

Of course, these steps seem very rational—and they don’t describe the tears and frustration that normally accompany situations like this. Despite the intensity of these emotions, children are very motivated to learn more about how conflict works and how it gets resolved.

 Helpful Parenting Tips
  • Understand that young children are constantly testing their environment. These children aren’t bad, they’re curious. Expect them to test you often.
  • Provide consistent responses. When children test their hypotheses, they are gathering evidence about how people deal with conflict. The best evidence is communicated in a reliable, consistent and loving way.
  • Don’t let hypothesis testing escalate your emotions. Keep emotions in check and remove a child (or tempting object) from a situation if the conflict continues.
  • Focus on the positive aspects of this age. These toddlers are not only learning how conflict happens, but how conflict gets resolved. If they are surrounded with healthy, consistent models, children can learn how to handle future disagreements in constructive and effective ways.
  • Hang in there! The age of two, and the difficultchallenges it can bring, doesn’t last forever.

References:

Gopnik, A., Meltzoff, A. N., & Kuhl, P. K. (1999). The scientist in the crib: What early learning tells us about the mind. New York: Perennial.

Repacholi, B. M., & Gopnik, A. (1997). Early reasoning about desires: Evidence from 14- and 18-month-olds. Developmental Psychology, 33(1), 12-21.

Click here for PDF.
Also available in print from our store.
The information on this Spotlight is the property of Talaris Institute and protected under U.S. copyright and other laws.

 

Highlights

Email:


   
 
 

Talaris Institute © 2006